Hope: The Lazy Writer’s Alternative to Fear

Birds' playground.

Birds’ playground.

When I first moved to the Amazon in 2007, I would sit out on my balcony at the end of the day and watch the birds divebomb the exotic fruit trees or dance in the sky, doing their usual noisy evening rituals that I, not being even an amateur birder, didn’t understand. But I could appreciate them, and their cacophony and theatre against the backdrop of twilight made me glad to be alive and grateful to be in a place where the life of other species takes center stage.

Bit by bit, though, my hope started to vanish. Although I consider myself a generally optimistic person who believes in the goodness of people, for several years I struggled with pessimism, bordering on despair. There were many reasons for this, some of which I’ve touched on in this blog. My basic, bleak question grew out of my sense of self as a writer. If, as scientists predict, we are really irrevocably depleting the resources upon which we’ve built not just life but civilization, what is the point of making art?

Art, after all, is one of the hallmarks of civilization as anthropologists and archeologists define it. When societies advance to the point where they have specialization, division of labor, and a certain degree of wealth and leisure, art is possible. Is it possible if a society is moving in the other direction?

I mulled this question. I saw a lot of disturbing signs that the answer was somewhere between no, art is not possible to yes, art is possible but ultimately ineffectual if we are on a slow descent into survival mode.

I found it harder to talk myself out of my funk and easier to give in to the fear and resignation swirling all around me. The evidence was compelling and difficult to argue. People who talked about a gradual awakening in human consciousness seemed delusionally idealistic to me, even though I’d built my life around those views and had sometimes been dismissed by the very pessimists that I now resembled.

Then, rather suddenly, something changed, and I started to believe in possibility again. I don’t know why exactly.

Was it evidence? The International Energy Agency’s report calling for a limit on fossil fuel consumption? Sold out venues on Bill McKibben’s cross-country tour to promote divestment from the oil industry? The soul-searching that followed the mass shootings at Sandy Hook Elementary School from such unexpected sources as Joe Scarborough? The fact that we survived that pesky Mayan calendar?

Maybe in part, though clearly there’s still plenty of evidence to indicate that our downward spiral continues. I think a bigger part is that I just got sick of living in fear. Hope started to seem like less work.

Hope can sometimes be just a mask for fear, an optimistic desperation that what we want to happen had better come to pass, or else. Hope can also be the pretext for a congenial apathy, a way to insulate ourselves from what we don’t like about the world and justify our inaction to change those things.

Maybe my original sense of hope was built on one or both of those rationales and was therefore doomed to disintegrate. The hope that is emerging now seems  almost indifferent to me, like the birds that flew around my balcony. It’s just there, doing what it does, and I can choose to take part in it or not. My fear doesn’t factor into the equation.

My excuses for avoiding the blank page are now starting to fray–ever so slightly–at the edges. While I am still pondering the question of producing art in a society in decline, at least I am now discovering more moments where I can set it aside. Is that a by-product of hope, or is it hope that gives me that capacity?

Another question I can’t answer. In any case, on a frigid, birdless day in Portland, Oregon where I’m writing this post,  I feel wonder and possibility along with a recognition of the serious challenges that lie ahead in 2013. And still I feel like writing. That’s reason enough to celebrate the new year.


4 thoughts on “Hope: The Lazy Writer’s Alternative to Fear

  1. In hope lies so much more possibility, as you know. So glad you moved out of the despair and into a place where you “feel like writing.” Thanks for sharing the evidence that there is movement toward a more sustainable way of living. Jane Goodall literally carries around symbols of hope, like a small chunk of rock from the island where Nelson Mandela was imprisoned, reminding her that positive change is possible. It seems to me that if we train our sites on hope, we notice good changes in society that we may have missed if our sites were on fear. It is a challenge to move from fear to love and hope. But as you say, one gets sick of living in fear. Let’s keep supporting each other to be in hope and in art.

  2. What a great post. Thanks for this, Mary.

    I think for me it’s a matter of choosing to spend my precious moments on this planet doing things that bring me joy, like writing. And believe it or not, that has been a struggle. It’s easy to deny myself pleasure and in fact, my culture reinforces that denial in many ways: Oh, there are so many other more useful things I could and should be doing than writing, gardening, and cooking! But doing those things that are joyful celebrates this sacred life and keeps me from frittering away my brief time here worrying about things beyond my control (or living in fear, as you put it).

    On the other hand, I do think it’s important to be very concerned about and to take action where one can (which is its own pleasure) with regards to the dire challenges we face. We must do what we can to make sure civilization and art continue. As you know, I’m also not very hopeful about The Future, but I get by in my daily life by trying to practice joy.

    I hope you’ll write more about this soon.

  3. Thank you so much to everyone who has commented on this post. It’s wonderful to hear others’ perspectives on this complex issue.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s